I feel that apple watch is not as accurate in detecting sleep as Xiaomi Mi Band
by Poster
Mar 5, 2025
48
I also bought autosleep and feel that the analysis of deep and light sleep is okay
Sometimes I fall asleep watching TV on the sofa at seven or eight o'clock in the evening. After sleeping for dozens of minutes, I can't detect it at all. The Xiaomi Mi Band can detect it: (
Replies
-
Anonymous4478 Mar 5, 2025I have tested it before by wearing Xiaomi Mi Band 4 and S7 in my left and right hands respectively, and the built-in ones are indeed not as accurate as Xiaomi Mi Band. After autosleep training, it is quite accurate, and you can recognize it after taking a nap on the high-speed train.
-
Anonymous10137 Mar 5, 2025Not so obsessive-compulsive, 😆
-
Anonymous8495 Mar 5, 2025Is sleep mode turned on? If it is not turned on, it should not be detected.
-
Anonymous2160 Mar 5, 2025This short sleep trigger is regarded as the shortcoming of apple watch, but in terms of data accuracy during sleep, apple is the most accurate among all smart watches.
-
Anonymous10528 Mar 5, 2025The mechanism is different, whether it is accurate is another matter
-
Anonymous10997 Mar 5, 2025The algorithm of apple watch is that the longer you wear it, the more accurate it is, including heart rate, aerobic and electrocardiogram, etc., which is almost comparable to the results of hospital physical examination. The most important thing is to look at the long-term trend, rather than whether a certain result is accurate or not. There is no meaning
-
Anonymous9701 Mar 5, 2025@ Anonymous10997 Yes, what Apple doesn't do well is meaningless (dog head)
-
Anonymous11007 Mar 5, 2025Apple Watch doesn't have automatic detection function
-
Anonymous8944 Mar 5, 2025For users like me who only see how long I sleep in a day (including naps), Xiaomi Mi Band is particularly good
-
Anonymous4479 Mar 5, 2025@ Anonymous8495 # 3 You have to turn on sleep mode before going to bed, so what's the point of sleep monitoring?
-
Anonymous4479 Mar 5, 2025@ Anonymous10137 @ Anonymous10528 @ Anonymous10997 This adaptability is amazing
-
Anonymous8495 Mar 5, 2025@ Anonymous4479 # 10 How do I know, I always think this thing is unreliable as a medical product 😂 Normally, according to my biological clock, which goes to bed at 10 o'clock and gets up at 6 o'clock, I set it to automatically enter the sleep mode at 10 o'clock in the evening, and the wake-up alarm clock automatically cancels the sleep mode. The sleep monitoring during this period is very accurate. I don't have the habit of sleeping during the day either, so the experience is fine.
-
Anonymous4480 Mar 5, 2025Yes, yes, Xiaomi's sleep monitoring is really a bit strong, I can take a nap accurately to the minute (I used Xiaomi Mi Band 6)
-
Anonymous4347 Mar 5, 2025Can't you detect temporary sleep after the update? Can you detect it lying on your desk at noon
-
Anonymous1679 Mar 5, 2025No matter how I wear a short sleep, it can be detected, but the Xiaomi Mi Band cannot detect it
-
Anonymous4481 Mar 5, 2025What is the use of apple watch besides detecting sleep? Too power-hungry
-
Anonymous2907 Mar 5, 2025I have used Xiaomi Mi Band 5 and Apple Watch S9, and to be honest, Xiaomi's is much more accurate
-
Anonymous10639 Mar 5, 2025Don't feel it, it's just not accurate, and it's not as accurate as Xiaomi Mi Band with third-party software
-
Anonymous10528 Mar 5, 2025@ Anonymous4481 # 16 It's useless, and sleep monitoring is not accurate
-
Anonymous4482 Mar 5, 2025I bought apple watch and autosleep. The conclusion is that aw's sleep detection is really average