I feel that apple watch is not as accurate in detecting sleep as Xiaomi Mi Band
by Poster
Mar 5, 2025
48
I also bought autosleep and feel that the analysis of deep and light sleep is okay
Sometimes I fall asleep watching TV on the sofa at seven or eight o'clock in the evening. After sleeping for dozens of minutes, I can't detect it at all. The Xiaomi Mi Band can detect it: (
Replies
-
Anonymous10084 Mar 5, 2025Only sleep mode will detect
-
Anonymous9417 Mar 5, 2025I just bought the apple watch after it was said on the Internet that it was accurate I went to bed after 12 o'clock last night, but I started to count my sleep time at 10:30... But Xiaomi's is sure to start the clock when you lie still The real depth statistics are not accurate either.
-
Anonymous10085 Mar 5, 2025Has anyone compared Huawei bracelets statistically? I currently have a Huawei Band 9, but I don't know if the sleep detection is accurate
-
Anonymous10086 Mar 5, 2025Xiaomi's mobile phone detection is more accurate than Apple Watch
-
Anonymous10087 Mar 5, 2025So far, I haven't seen any digital We Media reviewer in China who has done a systematic heart rate/sleep detection accuracy test to compare it with medical-grade monitoring equipment. I will only make the ratio of 4 heart rate sensors > 2 sensors like a primary school student, and repeat the specifications and parameters of the manufacturer's publicity draft according to the script. In short, it can prove that the manufacturer's products are the best in the world, but in fact they have no ability to evaluate them. My personal experience is that after using Xiaomi Mi Band 8 Pro, the heart rate on the elliptical machine is about to explode if it exceeds 140. The display on the bracelet has just reached 100, and the data cannot be used to judge exercise intensity at all.
-
Anonymous2681 Mar 5, 2025@ Anonymous10085 You can check this website https://watchpk.work/or you can go to bilibili to search for communication components
-
Anonymous3313 Mar 5, 2025@ Anonymous10088 is somatosensory heart rate? I just tried it two days ago, with an apple watch s8 in one hand and a Xiaomi Mi Band 9 in the other. The heart rates of both were measured exactly the same, but the final number difference was 1 or 2, which shows that the heart rate detection of both was very accurate.
-
Anonymous10089 Mar 5, 2025@ Anonymous9417 Xiaomi doesn't time when you lie down and stay still. You can usually write it down when you doze off while sitting. When you wake up in the morning, you lie down without moving your left hand. If you swipe your tablet/mobile phone with your right hand, you won't be counted as sleeping
-
Anonymous4932 Mar 5, 2025One thing to say, my Xiaomi bracelet is really accurate. I don't understand the depth of sleep, so I won't talk about it, but the duration is really accurate, and the nap is accurate to minutes
-
Anonymous2544 Mar 5, 2025I think the sleep detection of the new Xiaomi Mi Band is a bit long. For example, if you don't sleep or suffer from insomnia, it will also detect your sleep. On the contrary, the old Xiaomi Mi Band is more accurate. op should post a model of both
-
Anonymous5532 Mar 5, 2025@ Anonymous10086 is outrageous. How can the mobile phone detect it? Can you trust this data?
-
Anonymous2377 Mar 5, 2025I downloaded autosleep and it was okay, nap can basically detect it
-
Anonymous373 Mar 5, 2025@ Anonymous10087 Someone has measured the blood oxygen part, and it has slapped the blood oxygen test of many sports watches in the face, especially when the blood oxygen is low, the data is all randomly compiled As for sleep monitoring, it is a toy in itself. People's medical attention is apnea, not whether you sleep well or not
-
Anonymous10090 Mar 5, 2025Haha, you can say aw is accurate But coarse grain is right Hehe.. The brain magnification was raised
-
Anonymous10091 Mar 5, 2025https://watchpk.work/#/watch/sleep Someone has done a review
-
Anonymous10092 Mar 5, 2025I have used Xiaomi Mi Band 8pro and check last night's sleep record every morning. It is indeed accurate. Later, when I cycled, I paused the record at the traffic light and then turned on the record. After changing the watch, but I didn't care about the sleep time because it was inaccurate..
-
Anonymous10093 Mar 5, 2025@ Anonymous10087 I measured it with a heart rate belt. When wearing the Mihuan 9, I performed cycling exercise without loosening it. Except that the heart rate change is delayed than the heart rate belt, the heart rate range and curve are no different from the heart rate belt. However, the bracelet is not comfortable to wear firmly, or the heart rate band is comfortable
-
Anonymous10094 Mar 5, 2025@ Anonymous4479 Others don't care or care more about other things, just adaptation
-
Anonymous4479 Mar 5, 2025@ Anonymous10094 Yes, it's adaptive. If it's accurate, they will care. It's another set of words. Is there a question?
-
Anonymous9833 Mar 5, 2025After watchOS 10, you can detect whether you have fallen asleep without turning on sleep mode. The format of sleep display in non-sleep mode is different, and it does not distinguish between depth, core, and speed. During the Chinese New Year, I tested it personally, and the sleep on the high-speed rail was also detected, which was included in the total sleep of the day. That is to say, 6 hours in sleep mode and 2 hours of short sleep in other time periods add up to 8 hours of total sleep that day. 🌝 It really wasn't possible before, but now it is possible. The watch is S7. Whether it's accurate or not is another matter.