Pure macOS native, which one is better, surge or stash?
by Poster
May 9, 2025
72
Small rockets and loons must turn off sip before they can be used, which is very inconvenient
surge and stash are both expensive, I would like to ask which of these two is better to buy
At present, all of them are big version buyouts. There is no real lifetime, only big version...
Replies
-
Anonymous7489 May 9, 2025surge is quite stable
-
Anonymous7339 May 9, 2025@ Anonymous8449 Could you please tell me if the stability of a gateway is the same as that of a stand-alone machine? Is there a bottleneck if dozens of computers in the LAN are used?
-
Anonymous44 May 9, 2025If there is no need for advertising, the clash system is undoubtedly the best choice.
-
Anonymous3124 May 9, 2025@ Poster solved the case, you turn off sip, those iOS apps are not allowed to open when sip is turned off
-
Anonymous7490 May 9, 2025Is there any special use for this thing? I just installed an open source and free clash verge and used it, and it never felt like it was wrong
-
Anonymous11082 May 9, 2025Is sip that security policy? It's the same on my side, but then I changed it to the low-security one myself, and it's quite good now https://i.imgur.com/FWshy4B. png
-
Anonymous9865 May 9, 2025@ Anonymous9865 # 11 just finished saying that my family IP was blocked by V2EX, and 😂 slapped me in the face.
-
Anonymous8449 May 9, 2025@ Anonymous7339 There should be no bottleneck in terms of the number of connections for dozens of stable units. Anyway, after the number of connections goes up, zte's junk gigabit optical modem hangs up before surge
-
Anonymous1839 May 9, 2025@ Anonymous7490 # 25 Without mitm and some convenient modules, I can't go to advertisements and the like
-
Anonymous8449 May 9, 2025@ Anonymous7339 to add my topology Optical modem bridging openwrt in x86 is responsible for pppoe and dhcp surge is specified by dhcp as gateway and dns provider Finally, Wi-Fi access is provided with ap mesh The most stable one here is surge. I don't restart it once a year I have more than 20 pcs/tablets/phones and more than 20 other iots on my intranet
-
Anonymous902 May 9, 2025Clash Verge Rev on mac
-
Anonymous2392 May 9, 2025Wrong, this kind of iOS app must turn on SIP before it can be used. If you turn off SIP or do not fully turn on SIP, it is indeed impossible to use it. Maybe surge or singbox is a better choice
-
Anonymous2773 May 9, 2025surge is relatively cost-effective to share with others
-
Anonymous5743 May 9, 2025QX has a mac version enough
-
Anonymous7491 May 9, 2025surge beats stash, stash is really difficult to use.
-
Anonymous6741 May 9, 2025What device does @ Anonymous8449 install surge on? Mac mini? Or Apple TV?
-
Anonymous10901 May 9, 2025These iOS software requires sip to be used, are you wrong?
-
Anonymous2277 May 9, 2025stash I think is pretty good and never drops the chain, but I haven't compared surge.
-
Anonymous3272 May 9, 2025Surge is easy to use, Stash is just Clash hardcover
-
Anonymous6520 May 9, 2025@ Anonymous330 +1, the fragmentation of multi-terminal management configuration is the most troublesome. mac + iPhone + appletv quanx (current solution): The mac version is not native. If you want to connect to the company's vpn, you need to close it first and then open it, which is a little troublesome loon: Don't have a mac version yet? Or is it the ipad version? I tried loon on mac, which is better than quanx Hainan Little Rocket hasn't tried it. (None of the above has closed sip, the latest system, no problem) The stash has not been used, the surge is too expensive, just for the wall isn't worth it. If you use clash on mac, you need to manage configuration files on multiple terminals, which will be very troublesome, especially for the management of more rules